If one DeepSeek endpoint receives shorter prompts, fewer concurrent requests, or a different output limit, the comparison no longer isolates provider performance. A reproducible test controls the request, traffic, and measurement definitions, then publishes enough detail for another team to repeat it.
The goal is not to create one permanent leaderboard. It is to measure which provider fits a defined workload at a defined point in time.
1. Freeze the Workload and Measurement Boundaries
Start with a versioned dataset of representative prompts. Separate different workload classes instead of averaging them together. For DeepSeek, that might include short chat, structured extraction, code generation, and long-document analysis.
For every class, fix:
- Model alias and relevant version information
- Input-token distribution
- Requested and observed output-token distribution
- Streaming mode
- Reasoning, tools, sampling, and structured-output settings
- Timeout and retry policy
- Client region and network path
Use the same tokenizer or the provider-reported usage consistently. Send unique prompts when measuring uncached inference. If caching is part of the application, test it as a separate workload and report the expected hit rate.
Define timers before collecting results. TTFT should run from request dispatch to the first response token. Generation speed should state whether it begins at the first token or at request dispatch. End-to-end latency should end only after a complete response is received.
Define success just as carefully. A 200 status with a broken stream is not a completed request. A structurally valid response that fails the task may be operationally successful but should fail the separate quality evaluation.
2. Apply Load in Controlled Steps
Use open-loop, fixed pacing so the generator sends requests at the intended rate without waiting for previous requests to complete. A closed-loop test can make a slow provider look stable because slow responses automatically reduce new traffic.
Begin below the expected capacity and increase load in steps—for example, 500, 1,000, 2,500, and 5,000 RPM. Hold each level for a fixed duration. Record offered requests, completed requests, active concurrency, input and output TPM, and errors by category.
Before the test, define the acceptance rule. One example is at least 99% completed requests and TTFT p95 no higher than five seconds. The highest stable level is the last level that satisfies every rule, not the first level that produces any successful traffic.
Warm up connections and clients before measurement. Avoid changing client machines or network locations between providers. Randomize provider order when possible so time-of-day effects do not consistently favor one endpoint.
Repeat the run. Short tests find immediate saturation; longer soak tests reveal periodic contention and performance drift. Report sample size and the exact observation window with every percentile.
3. Publish Results That Another Team Can Interpret
Token Forge Cloud's DeepSeek test provides an example of a qualified result. It used one organization and one API key, unique prompts, approximately 100 input tokens, about 140 output tokens, fixed pacing, and 90-second load levels.
| Model | Highest stable tested load | Success rate | TTFT p50 | TTFT p95 | Token throughput |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
deepseek-v4.1-flash |
5,000 RPM | 100% | 1.36 s | 1.97 s | >1.21M TPM |
deepseek-v4-pro |
2,500 RPM | 100% | 2.15 s | 2.82 s | >617K TPM |
kimi-k3 |
5,000 RPM | 100% | 0.96 s | 1.26 s | ~5M TPM |
glm-5.3 |
4,200 RPM | 99.95% | 1.89 s | 5.62 s | ~5.4M TPM |
glm-5.3-flash |
2,400 RPM | 100% | 2.01 s | 5.29 s | ~3.0M TPM |
The Kimi K3 and GLM rows come from separate tests, the Kimi K3 load test report and the GLM load test report: about 1,000 input and up to 300 output tokens per request, Kimi K3 with reasoning off, and GLM at low reasoning (it cannot be turned off). GLM is held to a TTFT p95 of 8 seconds rather than 5.
The table is useful because it reports load, success, tail latency, and token work together. Its limitation is equally clear: it represents a short-context workload with reasoning disabled. It should not be treated as a result for long documents or a different model configuration.
A complete comparison package should contain the prompt-set description, request parameters, traffic schedule, success rule, raw per-request timestamps, token usage, error categories, and calculation code. Remove sensitive prompt content if necessary, but retain lengths and workload categories.
When presenting the final ranking, avoid one blended score unless the weights are explicit. Show separate views for interactive latency, batch throughput, reliability, quality, and effective cost. A DeepSeek provider that is best for short chat may not be best for long-context batch work.
Reproducibility does not mean a provider will produce the same number forever. It means a future change can be measured against the same method, and another team can understand exactly what the result represents.